Search Results for:

In your opinion, what is the difference between opera and musical theater? Philip Glass, Composer

Philip Glass
Philip Glass
Photo courtesy Annie Ohayon Media Relations

I tend to call things “operas” that are done in opera houses. I sometimes will call a piece “music theater” instead of opera, because the producer of the work will request that I change the name because people are afraid of the word “opera,” and I always acquiesce. Basically, I don’t care what you call it…

I sometimes do pieces in small theaters, like In The Penal Colony, which is clearly an opera but is being billed as “music theater” in a new production at CSC. They prefer to call it “music theater” because it fits in with their programming philosophy. However in my catalog it’s listed as an opera, and will be billed as an “opera” when it is presented at the Staatstheater Darmstadt. It’s totally a practical distinction. It’s what the producers and audience feel most comfortable with.

Sweeney Todd was done at City Opera and I think of it as an opera, whereas other works by Sondheim are more clearly musical theater. But it’s quite subjective, isn’t it?

Thomas Buckner Re-Enters the Record Business

Space, Abrams, and Graves CDs
Space, Abrams, and Graves CDs
designed by Matt Schickele

New music baritone Thomas Buckner, founder of the legendary 1750 Arch Records, which released more than fifty creative record albums, recently announced the formation of a new label, Mutable Music.

Mutable Music will release recordings that promote creative contemporary music. A major focus of the label will be recordings that feature contemporary composer/performers in composed and improvisational settings.

“My motivation for doing this label came from the fact that, just as when I started [1750 Arch Records], there are all kinds of music that I wanted to see out there that other people are not particularly interested in recording,” Buckner stated in an interview.

There are four releases scheduled for spring 2001. The debut release will be The Visibility of Thought, the first-ever recording of Muhal Richard Adams’s classical compositions, played by Joseph Kubera (piano), Jon Deak (contrabass), Ethel (string quartet), Mark Feldman (violin), Thomas Buckner (baritone), Philip Bush (piano), and the composer (piano). “I think that it’s exceptional music,” Buckner commented. “He’s been composing and performing this kind of music throughout his whole career.” The disc includes Baritone Voice and String Quartet, written for Buckner, as well as Piano Duet #1, written for Ursula Oppens and Frederic Rzewski.

Composer Mel Graves has been a prominent music figure in the San Francisco area for the past 30 years. The disc Day of Love features the title track, based on poems by Pablo Neruda, also written for Buckner, and the quartet Global Village. Performances are by Buckner, Ethel, Robert Afifi (flute), and the composer (bass).

Next will come Space: New Music for Woodwinds and Voice/An Interesting Breakfast Combination. This is a reissue of the two critically acclaimed 1750 Arch Records (from 1981 and 1984) of composed and improvisational works by Roscoe Mitchell, Thomas Buckner, and the late Gerald Oshita.

Completing the initial quartet of releases will be Eight O’Clock: Two Improvisations. Since the late 1970s, Thomas Buckner has worked closely with composer/performer Roscoe Mitchell, one of the founding members of the Art Ensemble of Chicago. This recording documents some of their strongest work to date in their ongoing studies of improvisation since the formation of the trio “Space” (with Gerald Oshita) in 1979. The way Buckner explained it, he and Mitchell have been improvising together so long that they walked into a studio one day in December, decided to do “a long piece and a short piece,” and then simply recorded the results on the first take.

Plans for future releases include a recording of an improvised piece Jump the Circle/Jump the Line, performed live by Buckner and Tom Hamilton at Engine 27 in December 2000; a new recording of the solo percussion music of Jerome Cooper; and two 1750 Arch reissues: Ethnic Fusion, the music of Big Black and Anthony Wheaton; and Randy Weston‘s solo piano album Blue, complete with some newly recorded tracks.

Buckner stresses that Mutable is not solely a reissue label. “I’m reissuing people I still find interesting. Music is not objective, it’s subjective. [My selection process] is very arbitrary and capricious,” Buckner quipped. Even if he wanted to reissue the entire 1750 Arch collection, there are logistical problems. When he stopped 1750 Arch Records in 1984, Buckner initially sought to find an arrangement with a record company whereby the performers and composers would be able to access their master tapes. When no record company stepped forward, he decided, instead, simply to give the masters back to the composers and performers in question, enabling them to seek out re-release arrangements on their own.

According to Buckner, the name Mutable reflects his love of “music that changes. A lot of the music we have so far has an element of mutability, whether it’s improvisation or indeterminacy. There is an element in the music that isn’t completely fixed in the score.” Mutable could also apply to Buckner’s open-minded approach. “I’m not going to swear that we won’t do something completely different,” he explained. “I’m not going to let a concept keep me from putting out a recording that I want to put out.”

Muhal Richard Abrams’s The Visibility of Thought


Mel Graves’s Day of Love

In your opinion, what is the difference between opera and musical theater? Elizabeth Swados, Composer

Elizabeth Swados
Elizabeth Swados
Photo by Rosalind Lichter

I don’t think those words apply anymore to the creations of this time. “Opera” and “Musical Theater” are terms that come from specific times in history and we need new terms for our life in the present tense. New forms are fusing and colliding with old forms and it’s an exciting reinterpretation of theater and music.

Teldec Launches New Line

Sharon Isbin CD
Sharon Isbin

On February 26, 2001, Teldec announced New Line, a new series dedicated to the music of living composers and to world-premiere recordings of significant 20th century works. The first releases are scheduled for May 2001.

On May 15, New Line will release world-premiere recordings of Bang On A Can‘s Lost Objects: A Transmusicart Project, guitar concertos by Tan Dun and Christopher Rouse, and Luigi Nono‘s Al gran sole carico d’amore in the U.S.

Lost
Bang On A Can CD

Lost Objects was commissioned by the Dresden Music Festival and the RIAS Chamber Choir. The piece is an oratorio structured in eleven separate sections, each of which deals differently with the subject of “loss.” The texts that are set to music have been drawn from the Talmud, the Torah, and the Old Testament, texts that deal with lost religious rites and commandments; there are also texts dealing with the fates of people who have gone missing, such as the mountain climber George Leigh Mallory, who never returned from his Mount Everest climb in 1924. It is scored for a combination of Baroque instruments (represented by the Baroque ensemble Concerto Kˆln and the RIAS Chamber Choir), rock band, and DJ Spooky, who remixes the musical material.

Tan Dun’s Concerto for Guitar and Orchestra (Yi2) is part of a Yi1 cycle of concerti that comprises Yi0, an orchestral concerto on which he superimposed independent works for solo instruments. His inspiration for the Yi1 cycle is the Yi-Ching, or the Book of Changes, a Chinese philosophical work from the 5th century B.C. In Yi0, the orchestra is “that which already exists;” the solo is the “potential that is to be discovered.” In Yi2, Tan’s writing for the guitar was influenced rhythmically and melodically by Spanish flamenco music.

Christopher Rouse’s Concert de Gaudí also reveals the influence of flamenco music. The piece is named after the Catalonian architect Antoni Gaudí. “What has always struck me about Gaudí is his quintessentially Spanish combination of surrealism and mysticism, and I strove to include these elements in my concerto,” Rouse writes. “I used music that almost everyone would recognize as archetypically Spanish – flamenco – as the foundation for the score,” the composer has written. “I then proceeded to ‘melt,’ ‘bend,’ ‘mist,’ and otherwise transform this material into something I hoped would be musically akin to the way Gaudí would like a traditional design and add fanciful and phantasmagoric touches to make it unlike any other’s work.”

The two concerti represent Sharon Isbin‘s ninth and tenth commissions. She performs them with the Gulbenkian Orchestra under the direction of Muhai Tang.

New Line has signed two composers to exclusive contracts: Gyorgy Ligeti and the 30-year old German composer Matthias Pinscher. Over the next three years, Teldec will release five CDs of the senior composer’s works under the title “The Ligeti Project,” concentrating on a broad representation of his music and picking up the project where Sony Classical left off. The first release includes his Piano Concerto, Melodien, Chamber Concerto and Mysteries of the Macabre. Pinscher’s first recording, made with the NDR Orchestra under the direction of Christoph Eschenbach, includes Hériodiade ≠ Fragmente, music from Thomas Chatterton, and Sur “Départ.” The discs of Ligeti’s and Pinscher’s music will be released in the U.S. on June 15, 2001.

Arthur Moorhead
Arthur Moorhead
photo by Larry Busacca

“Since we’ve passed into the 21st century, there is this feeling that [in order to be] a company that artistically means something, you can’t just constantly document the past,” commented Arthur Moorhead, Vice-President of Associated Labels at Atlantic Records, Teldec’s parent company. “Museums have exhibitions of an historical nature, [but they also] go out on a limb and exhibit artists who are not yet established. Increasingly in our business, to be taken seriously as an artistic entity, you’ve got to be able to address the music of our time and the music of the future.”

Moorhead credits Martin Sauer, the President of Teldec, with the vision that has made New Line possible. “His commitment to living composers is driving this series,” Moorhead commented. “I don’t think that anyone thinks that this music is going to find its way to a mainstream audience. But composers, Martin [Sauer], and people at Teldec believe that these are recordings that people will listen to 50 years from now.” He admitted that a series of this kind presents “a real challenge for those of us who are judged on what kind of business we run. We’re going to do the best that we can to produce [the recordings] and market them.”

Marketing contemporary music, according to Moorhead, is not that different from marketing early music, something he has had experience with in the form of Teldec’s Das Alte Werk series. “We could be reaching as few as three or four thousand people,” he explained. “We can’t expect to run a full-page ad in Time and have any impact. [Our listeners are] people who listen to NPR, read The Utne Reader, are web-savvy.” He finds it interesting that early music listeners are frequently also new music listeners.

New Line’s function as a series will make it easier to market than the occasional “un-affiliated” new music release, Moorhead explained. “This is Teldec’s first concerted effort to present a real contemporary music series, both in terms of the underlying concept as to what kind of pieces to record, and in terms of packaging.” They are targeting an audience of 2500 to 5000, using what Moorhead calls “traditional elements of brand marketing, albeit on a smaller scale.” He hopes to create a positive kind of “brand recognition” for New Line among new music listeners. There are enough releases “in the pipeline,” Moorhead stated, to keep the series going for at least a couple of years.

One additional and little-publicized fact about New Line that may contribute to its success is the release of each recording into DVD-Audio format. The Bang On A Can Lost Objects recording, for instance, will be released onto DVD in the fall of 2001. Moorhead does not anticipate simultaneous CD/DVD-A releases for another two years, in keeping with the behavior of the rest of the industry.


Tan Dun’s Concerto for Guitar and Orchestra (Yi2)


Christopher Rouse’s Concert de Gaudí

In your opinion, what is the difference between opera and musical theater? Dominick Argento, Composer

Dominick Argento
Dominick Argento
Photo by Tom Foley, courtesy Boosey & Hawkes

When I think of opera, characters such as Figaro, Iago, Octavian and Mimi come to mind. When I think of musical comedy, songs such as “Old Man River,” Some Enchanted Evening,” “Tonight,” and “Send In The Clowns” come to mind. This is because operatic music is primarily concerned with defining characters and creating atmosphere, whereas the tunes of musical comedy are essentially decorative and ancillary. Notable exceptions exist on both sides of that distinction but the fact that the opera composer–unlike the musical comedy composer–is always the orchestrator permits, through the accompanying instrumental tone color and timbre, a much greater focus on the character’s persona. “Old Man River” is a beautiful song and practically any orchestration of it is adequate to make that point. “Iago’s Credo” is not especially beautiful (it was never meant to be) but its orchestration is indispensable for limning Iago and what drives him.

Musical comedy composers can specify the tempo of the songs but the pace of the drama, its point of view, color, etc., is determined by another party, the stage director. The piece can change significantly as it moves from production to production. In opera, tempo and atmosphere, character and situation, from beginning to end, are controlled by a single mind. That sort of artistic integrity explains why I believe La Bohéme will still be playing somewhere in the year 2100 while Rent will be a footnote in Broadway history.

George Crumb’s Star-Child wins Grammy

George Crumb
George Crumb
photo by Sabine Matthes

Congratulations to George Crumb on being honored with a Grammy for Best Classical Contemporary Composition at the 43rd annual presentation of the awards on February 21, 2001. The winning piece, Star-Child, for soprano, antiphonal children’s voices, male speaking choir, bell ringers, and large orchestra, was composed in 1977 and recorded on Bridge Records in 1999. The Bridge recording was produced by the label’s co-principal, David Starobin and features Susan Narucki, soprano; Joseph Alessi, solo trombone; the Warsaw Boys’ Choir; the Warsaw Philharmonic Choir; George Crumb and Paul Cesarczyk, bell ringers; the Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra; and Thomas Conlin, conductor.

The recording was funded in part by The Aaron Copland Fund. Other works on the all-Crumb CD are Mundus Canis (1998) (David Starobin, guitar, George Crumb, percussion) and Three Early Songs (1947) (Ann Crumb, soprano, George Crumb, piano). For an in-depth look at Star Child, its composer, and interviews with Conlin and Starobin, go to the American Symphony Orchestra League’s NewMusicNow website and click on “More Works to Explore.”

In your opinion, what is the difference between opera and musical theater? Mark Adamo, Composer and Librettist

Mark Adamo
Mark Adamo
Photo by Christian Steiner, courtesy G. Schirmer, Inc.

Even if we limit discussion to contemporary American work, we first need to define terms. The musical play, as defined by Rodgers and Hammerstein, extends from Oklahoma through Fiddler on theRoof to Ragtime. The songbook-style musical comedy, covers most of the Rodgers & Hart, Gershwin, Berlin, Comden and Green, and Jerry Herman shows: a new example is The Full Monty. With the latter, opera has little to do at all. With the former, one primary difference is that the books of the serious musicals are, for the most part, infinitely more intelligent about how to combine music and words for dramatic expression than most contemporary opera libretti, which are, bewilderingly often, written by writers experienced in every kind of writing except the theatrical.

But the theatre doesn’t encourage musical sophistication, only the sophisticated use of unsophisticated musical materials, which is why the only possible place that music-heavy shows like Rent or Les Miserables could be called operas would be on Broadway. The musical thinness is understandable, given the unreliable skills of that category “singing actor,” which has covered everyone from elegant croaker Rex Harrison to opera-singers-on-Broadway Alfred Drake and Barbara Cook. And the musical’s up-from-songbook history has sown, if not active resistance, than striking disinterest in the idea of symphonic or motivic development as analogous to dramatic process. Conversely, American opera hasn’t always encouraged theatrical sophistication, just the musically sophisticated elaboration of theatrically often simple-minded ideas. The skill-sets of the usual performers are again germane here, because the category of “acting singer” has included everyone from Lauren Flanigan to Luciano Pavarotti.

As economic quantities, obviously, they’re part of different cultural categories: Musicals belong to the business of theatre, which retains its shimmer of populism despite $80.00 Broadway tickets, while opera belongs to the business of “elitist” classical music. There are technical differences, too. Musicals are amplified these days (though ‘twas not ever thus): operas not, for reasons good (few know how to do so either appropriately or creatively) and ill (the new fundamentalism about the sacrality of the acoustic voice, a catechism about as sensible as loyalty to gut strings or the fortepiano.) Composers orchestrate their own operas: theatre composers almost never score their own shows. Most actresses sing about a fifth lower than their operatic counterparts, with more use (and abuse) of the chest voice; men sing about a third lower (though A Little Night Music calls for tenor high-B’s.) Opera singers are invariably better musicians, and generally have broader ranges and more (unamplified) dynamic and timbral control. Theatre singers are generally, though not always, more methodical and resourceful actors. There are, for the composer and librettist, no other substantial artistic differences at all. When I composed Little Women, I imagined writing the libretto for Broadway and the score for Lincoln Center, much as, I imagine, did the writers of Porgy and Bess and Candide. In every production so far, the farce scene that most regularly plays like that of a musical comedy is, coincidentally, the scene most driven by twelve-tone recitativo secco. When talking about opera and musical theatre, the operative word has to be AND.

Yehudi Wyner Signs with Associated Music Publishers

Yehudi Wyner
Yehudi Wyner
photo by Susan Davenny Wyner

Associated Music Publishers, Inc. has announced the signing of Yehudi Wyner to an exclusive five-year agreement in which the company will represent the music formerly self-published by Wyner.

“It’s been a long exile, but I feel I’m coming home,” said Wyner after his 10-year absence from Associated Music Publishers. “[Schirmer/AMP has] participated in the evolution of a thriving enterprise. . .supported above all by faith and vision and by the clearheaded belief that business and quality are not irreconcilable antagonists.”

Schirmer/AMP vice president Susan Feder observes, “Yehudi Wyner possesses a rare gift of compelling, expressive, immediate, individual musicianship. We welcome him home and are delighted once again to have the opportunity to bring music of such quality to a place of wider recognition and appreciation.”

With his return, Wyner brings a diverse catalog of works for orchestra, chamber ensemble, chorus, voice, solo instrumental works, liturgical settings, as well as music for klezmer ensemble.

For more information, click here.

In your opinion, what is the difference between opera and musical theater? Diane Wondisford, Producing Director, Music-Theatre Group

Diane Wondisford
Diane Wondisford

The differences that exist between opera and music theatre, have to do with form, dramatic structure, scale, style, and tone. In opera, the story is conveyed through aria and recitative, very rarely unaccompanied spoken word, and sometimes the dance.

In the creation of a music-theatre piece, artists borrow from many forms and structures. Sometimes, a music theatre piece will take the form of “the musical” where the story is carried in song, spoken dialogue, and dance. Often music and text are equal partners on the stage; i.e. poetry and jazz. Music-theatre composers often reach into more contemporary musical idioms, i.e. popular song, world music, hip-hop, etc.

As opera companies include time-honored American musicals in their repertoire and theatres produce opera, the distinctions between the two worlds are becoming blurred. Composers look to the operatic form through the prism of contemporary music to create their new work and have arrived at interesting fusions; jazz opera, for example.

For my part, I think the most compelling new music-theatre work combines the best of both worlds. It is happening on a chamber scale, where all of the elements – music, theatre, dance and the visual arts – are combined in highly theatrical ways. Scale in this context supports experimentation and risk.

AAAL Announces 2001 Award Winners: Gerald Plain

Gerald Plain
Gerald Plain
photo by Louis Ouzer

Gerald Plain has had his compositions performed by the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra, the Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra, the Brooklyn Philharmonic, the Philharmonic Orchestra of Monte Carlo, and the Louisville Orchestra. His awards include an Artists’ Fellowship from the New York Foundation of the Arts, a Charles Ives Fellowship from the American Academy of Arts and Letters, a residency at the Millay Colony, the Prince Pierre of Monaco Musical Composition Prize, a National Endowment for the Arts Composer Fellowship Grant, the Prix de Rome, and a Rackham Block Grant from the University of Michigan. He has taught at the Eastman School of Music, the University of Wisconsin Stevens Point, Roosevelt University, DePaul University, and Texas Tech University. Dr. Plain’s music is published by Oxford University Press.

“My music is clearly influenced by my Southern roots,” Plain commented in an interview. “My Granddaddy Salmon was a folksinger, and my parents were into church music and folk music.” As a teenager, Plain played the pedal steel guitar and had a band that played square-dance music as well as rock and roll. “I started composing when I went to college,” he explained. “There was a contemporary arts festival at Murray State [University], and I became fascinated by the music of the Second Viennese School.” While at Murray State, he also heard the music of Howard Hanson, Walter Piston, and others. His bass professor had studied with Hindemith at Yale, and it was he who introduced Plain to the string quartets of BartÛk. Plain later went on to study composition with Ross Lee Finney and Leslie Bassett at the University of Michigan.

Plain is currently working on a concerto for the recorder player Piers Adams. The concerto will be scored for solo recorder, string ensemble, harpsichord, and percussion. Plain plans on making an arrangement of one movement of the concerto for Adams’ ensemble Red Priest, a mixed quartet of recorder, violin, cello, and harpsichord. He is also working on an orchestra piece of an autobiographical nature.

The recorder concerto is somewhat unique in Plain’s music for its lack of folk-music influence. Much of his orchestra music features recognizable folk music tunes. Plain’s 1975 orchestra piece and left ol’Joe a bone, AMAZING! includes references to “Old Joe Clark” and “Amazing Grace.” The American folk tunes “Pretty Polly” and “Sally Goodin” make appearances in his two Portraits for orchestra from the late 1980s.

At present, no recording of Plain’s music is available; a recording of his music was made in the early 1970s on the Advance label, but has never been reissued. Plain hopes that the $7500 designated for recording will help him to bring one step closer to fruition a long-held dream: a CD of his orchestra music. According to Plain, several conductors have approached him about recording his music, but as yet he has not come up with the funds to make it possible. “[This award] is going to be a good thing,” he commented, “because recording orchestra music is prohibitively expensive.”